| 1563. | Marvin | 161, 256 |
| 1747. | Marvin, 1796- | 168 |
| 1578. | Marvin, 1799- | 162 |
| 3085. | Marvin, 1822- | 225, 323 |
| 1385. | Maryetta, 1826- | 155 |
| 3838 | Mason, 1822-, (listed as Erasmus Mason) | 250, 351 |
| 1447. | Matilda, 1796- | 157 |
| 12677. | Matilda, 1835- | 490 |
| 6032. | Matilda, 1864- | 332 |
| 5402. | Matthew Gresham, 1890- | 312 |
| 7532. | Mattie L., 1871- | 375, 464 |
| 7433. | Maud | 369, 459 |
| 7700. | Maud | 381 |
| 8752. | Maude, 1878- | 402 |
| 6202b. | Maud Albion, 1875- | 337 |
| 6060. | Maud Lytte, 1885- | 334 |
| 7525d. | May Belle, 1892- | 372 |
| 4506. | May W., 1872- | 273 |
| 1122. | Melissa, 1828- | 146 |
| 559. | Menardus, 1770- | 103, 150 |
| 492. | Mercy | 99 |
| 1141. | Mercy | 147 |
| 149. | Mercy, 1739- | 45 |
| 188. | Mercy, 1742- | 49 |
| 12592. | Mercy, 1797- | 487 |
| 1511a. | Mercy M., 1738- | 159 |
| 6901. | Merchant | 359 |
| 5227. | Merton, 1869- | 303 |
| 5469. | Mildred Belle, 1895- | 315 |
| 10076. | Mildred Cary, 1885- | 449 |
| 4532. | Miles | 275 |
| 1872. | Millicent, 1815- | 175 |
| 1809. | Milton | 170, 273 |
| 1812. | Milton, 1820- | 171, 274 |
| 1806. | Milton A., 1813- | 170, 272 |
| 9700. | Milton Bertrand, 1891- | 435 |
| 742. | Milton H., 1783- | 114, 170 |
| 237. | Mindwell, 1732- | 54 |
| 1788. | Minerva | 170 |
| 3910. | Minerva | 253 |
| 661. | Minerva, 1772- | 109 |
| 1510. | Minerva, 1803- | 159, 249 |
| 6584 | Minerva, 1883 (listed as A. Minerva) | 347 |
| 3771. | Minerva, 1823- | 247, 347 |
| 782. | Minerva Kezia, 1804- | 119, 177 |
| 9840. | Minnie, 1879- | 438 |
| 7531. | Minnie R., 1869- | 375, 464 |
| 6135. | Minnie Truesdell, 1862- | 336 |
| 1519c. | Miranda A., 1806- | 159 |
| 4175. | Miriam D., 1808- | 259 |
| 1711. | Miss--? | 165 |
| 673. | Mollie, 1761- | 109 |
| 195. | Molly, 1761- | 49 |
| 1784. | Morgan, 1814- | 169, 272 |
| 4363. | Morgan H., 1827- | 266, 375 |
| 226. | Moses, 1727- | 52 |
| 169. | Moses, 1743- | 46, 100 |
| 676. | Moses, 1766- | 110, 161 |
| 1506. | Moses, 1795- | 159, 248 |
| 1502. | Myron, 1787- | 158, 246 |
| 6570. | Myron Ward, 1841- | 346, 443 |
| 7831. | Myrtle | 383 |